Your Definitive Vintage Style Home Decor Shopping List: 13 Must-Have Finds

There’s nothing quite like the thrill of a great vintage find. The perfect worn-in leather chair, a timeless mid-century coffee table, or a set of delicate porcelain vases that feel straight out of a Parisian flea market. But seasoned vintage shoppers know that finding those true treasures takes more than just luck. Whether you’re shopping for your house in San Francisco, CA, an apartment in Atlantic City, NJ, or a rental home in Tampa, FL, knowing what to look for can make all the difference. 

To help you navigate the world of secondhand shopping, we reached out to vintage experts for their go-to tips. From spotting quality materials to identifying hidden gems, consider this your insider’s guide to shopping smarter, scoring big, and curating a home full of pieces of history.

Tips to consider before purchasing

Start small

Diving into the world of vintage home decor can feel overwhelming, but starting with smaller, decorative pieces is a great way to ease into the process. Nicole Forina, a Tinton Falls, NJ-based designer of Nicole Forina Home recommends beginning your journey with these versatile finds. “When searching for vintage pieces, starting small always feels less intimidating.”

“It’s easy to begin with colorful Murano glass bowls, elegant glassware for a hutch or open-shelf bar, brass sculptures, small oil paintings, or copper kitchenware. Find what speaks to you and start a collection—because nothing is more exciting than the thrill of the hunt in the world of antiquing.”

Search high and low

When browsing for vintage home decor, it pays to keep your eyes peeled and your perspective wide. Jennifer Sanchez from the Murfreesboro, TN non-profit organization, Steered Straight Thrift, encourages shoppers to explore every nook and cranny. “Look up, look down, look behind, and look all around when you walk into a thrift store. Hidden treasures are everywhere. Most antique stores know what they have and may ask for a pretty penny for the item. However, some thrift stores don’t know what they have until ‘it’ walks out the door.”

Quality is important

When shopping for furniture, craftsmanship matters. “Quality is important—that means solid wood pieces when possible, structurally sound frames, easy-sliding intact drawers, and solid drawer construction, such as Knapp joints or dovetail joinery,” explains Kristie, founder of Lucky Furniture Co. in Seattle, WA. That said, not every piece needs to be perfect. “If that Art Deco vanity you adore has wood veneer, doesn’t have dovetail construction drawers, or is missing a piece of hardware, it’s not a dealbreaker.” Minor imperfections can often be easily restored. The key is knowing what’s worth fixing and what might be costly to your wallet.

Inspect before you invest

When shopping for vintage home decor, appearances can be deceiving. That antique dresser or ornate mirror might look flawless at first glance, but there could be unseen issues. “Look at the entire piece including the back, inside, and undersides,” advises Jay Gates, owner of Gates Antiques Ltd in Richmond, VA. “Be sure to pull any drawers out and examine them and where they fit. Repair work is expensive. If in doubt, walk away.”

Photo courtesy of Nicole Forina Home

1. Vintage Furniture

In the world of home decor, vintage style furniture is experiencing a well-deserved resurgence. Timeless and full of allure, pieces like sculptural chairs and statement buffets can become the foundation of a curated, storied interior.

Chairs

Vintage chairs bring an effortless elegance to any room, combining style and history in a way modern pieces simply lack. Heather from Citrine Casa highlights the value of vintage dining chairs, calling them a “designer’s secret weapon.” She explains, “Antique furniture, unlike today’s mass-produced pieces, was crafted with exceptional quality and built to last generations, showcasing solid woods, rich patinas, and hand-finished details.” 

Beyond aesthetics, vintage chairs are an investment in durability—often outlasting new furniture while being similarly priced. “Don’t be afraid to mix and match styles for a curated look,” Heather advises.

Beyond classic dining chairs, mid-century modern seating offers another avenue for vintage lovers. The team at Rescue Vintage, a Seattle, WA-based furniture restoration service, recommends seeking out high-quality vintage alternatives to classics. “If you love the look of the iconic Eames lounge chair and ottoman but not the price, look for vintage copycat models made by Selig and Plycraft, which are high-quality look-alikes made in roughly the 1960s-1980s. With professional reupholstering and refinishing, these chairs look smart with a range of interior styles. Just be sure to test the chair’s joints and ensure it sits upright before buying.”

Buffets

Once considered a relic of the past, vintage buffets are now a sought-after statement piece. “Deep brown, vintage furniture is making a comeback because it offers character, exceptional craftsmanship, and a sustainable alternative to mass-produced goods,” explains Genna from the Denver, NC vintage and antique shop, The Missing Piece Vintage. “Buffets, in particular, are timeless pieces that add individuality and depth to interior spaces, telling stories and introducing textures that modern furniture often lacks. Pairing a vintage buffet with contemporary dishes and serving pieces creates a dynamic and intriguing aesthetic.”

2. Antique mirrors

Timeless and effortlessly glamorous, antique mirrors never go out of style. These versatile pieces complement nearly any decor and serve as striking focal points while enhancing light and depth in a space.

“Vintage and antique mirrors not only add style and character, but they also bring light and a sense of openness, especially to darker spaces,” explains Simon Davies from Design by Davies. 

Simon goes into detail about how you can use mirrors strategically for the best results. “Consider placing a mirror opposite a window to reflect the outdoors and bring nature inside, or use one in a dark hallway or stairwell to brighten up the area. You can even get creative by incorporating a mirror as a backing for shelves or cabinets in the kitchen to enhance the overall aesthetic.”

Adding to this, Amber Novak from the online home decor shop, Gem Finds Vintage adds that antique mirrors are not only stylish but also widely accessible. “Mirrors can enhance natural light, create the illusion of space, and add character to any room. Best of all, they can be found at a variety of price points, making them an accessible and timeless vintage find.”

Photo courtesy of Design by Davies

3. Vintage lighting

The right vintage lighting doesn’t just illuminate a space—it transforms it. Whether you’re drawn to the grandeur of antique chandeliers, the bold charm of mid-century lamps, or the artistry of Italian designs, make sure to add these recommendations to your vintage style home decor shopping list.

Chandeliers

For an elegant look that will stand the test of time, antique brass chandeliers are a perfect choice. Troy McElfresh, auctioneer and owner of Mr. Bid Auctions in Muncie, IN, recommends these classic fixtures for their enduring appeal. “Antique brass chandeliers add elegance and warmth to any space while often featuring intricate craftsmanship that’s hard to find in modern lighting,” he shares. “Look for original patina and solid brass construction to ensure authenticity and long-term value.”

Lamps

If you’re looking to brighten up a space with a touch of personality, mid-century lamps are a must-have. “Unlike many of the run-of-the-mill lamps you can buy in today’s department stores, vintage lamps offer an alternative option that enhances your home aesthetic like no other,” says Stan Savellis, owner of the Australia-based vintage home shop, That Retro Piece. Both glass and ceramic bases were prominent throughout the mid-century period, often in bold colors and designs that are hard to find today. “These lamps are often paired with shades that complement either the color, shape, or texture of the base, making them a fantastic hero piece for any space in need of a wow factor.”

Italian lighting

When it comes to vintage lighting, Italian designs are often overlooked. From the wedding cake chandeliers to Murano glass pendants, these statement pieces can instantly make a room sparkle. As Summer, interior designer and owner of Summer Loftin Antiques based in Atlanta, GA describes, “Vintage shopping is all about the thrill of discovery, and Italian lighting remains one of the best-kept secrets.”

She suggests keeping an eye out for atomic task lamps, bamboo floor lamps, toile sconces, and alabaster table lamps. “Mid-century Italian designers like Gino Sarfatti, Stilnovo, and Venini mastered the balance of form and function, creating sculptural lighting that feels just as modern today as it did decades ago.” Her pro tip? Always remember to look up—you never know what Italian masterpiece might be hiding in plain sight.

4. Antique and vintage rugs

More than just floor coverings, antique and vintage rugs bring warmth, history, and character to a space. Their exceptional durability and timeless appeal make them a worthwhile investment that only gets better with age.

“Be on the lookout for these rugs, as they are timeless investments, especially those made from 100% wool,” advises Madissen Walker, owner and principal designer of Madissen Walker Interiors in Knoxville, TN. “Their longevity and quality make them a valuable addition to any home, as they not only enhance a space, but also retain their worth over time.”

Beyond their durability, vintage rugs can completely transform a room. Kate Lindsay Interior Design in Annapolis, MD emphasizes how vintage rugs can define a space. “Mixing in vintage pieces, especially my favorites of vintage artwork and rugs, introduces soul and depth into a space; a ‘collected over time’ feel,” explains Lindsay.

5. Brass pieces

Brass accents have long been a staple in vintage decor. From intricate trays to sculptural bookends, these pieces effortlessly complement a range of interior styles while adding a classic touch. “I never pass on quality brass elements,” shares Christy Grace from the vintage blog, The Vintage Eclectic. “Whether it’s a pair of candlestick holders or an ornate planter, brass accents add a sense of sophistication and charm to any decor style.” She particularly enjoys the natural patina that develops over time, preferring it to a polished look.

The team at the boutique, Dragonfly Thrift in South Miami, FL echoes this sentiment, noting the appeal of vintage brass. “They’re one of our favorite finds. These timeless and often quirky pieces are popular for a reason; they’re versatile, full of character, and give presence to any space. As an added bonus, they are easy to clean, fun, and lend themselves to different decorating styles.”

6. Glassware

When it comes to vintage style home decor, nothing elevates a display quite like a collection of glassware. “These will bring elegance and charm to your table, bar cart, or credenza,” says Jess Taylor, owner of the Ravenna, OH-based vintage shop and design studio, Peace, Love, and Vintage. She suggests seeking out Mid-Century cocktail sets, which are not only practical but also highly collectible. “Beautiful and bold Mid-Century cocktail sets are stylish and functional, with etched patterns, unique colors, or pressed designs that reflect their era.” 

Jess also encourages mixing and matching glassware pieces for an eclectic, curated look. “Keep an eye out for iconic brands like West Virginia Glass (Blendo), Fred Press, Culver, and Georges Briard,” she adds.

The team at Hanover Flea Market, known for its rare collectibles, antiques, books, vinyl, and more, notes that antique glass remains a favorite among shoppers. “Beautiful pieces such as milk glass, depression glass, fenton glass, uranium glass, hen on a nest, and carnival glass are just a few examples. Each style can satisfy the interest of most antique glass enthusiasts based on its color.”

7. Vintage crocks

Crocks are a simple yet charming way to infuse your space with a rustic, lived-in appeal. Honey Bee Vintage Home suggests, “A quick way to add a touch of vintage charm to your house is by sourcing vintage crocks or jars. Use them around your home for florals or greenery, makeup brushes, utensils, and more.”

Home and lifestyle influencer Brooke Donnelly also shares her personal love for these pieces. “I love looking for ceramic crocks whenever I’m thrifting, antiquing, or shopping estate sales. They add such an earthy and lived-in feel to your decor and you can use them for so many different things. Personally, I’ve used them for everything from potting plants to arranging flowers to holding kitchen utensils or simply styling on their own on a shelf or table.” For Brooke, “The more worn and chipped the finish, the better.”

8. Pyrex

Vintage Pyrex is more than just kitchenware—it’s a nostalgic treasure that connects us to the past while serving modern-day function. Known for its vibrant colors and iconic designs, Pyrex has become a beloved collectible, adored for both its practicality and its sentimental appeal.

As the antique shop, Your Antique Marketplace in Auburn, WA, explains, “Pyrex’s popularity is due to the nostalgia factor. Many collectors love Pyrex simply because it reminds them of childhood. With all of the colors and designs Pyrex provided over the years it’s not only an item still used by many today, but is also a fun display piece for the trending open shelving many are going with in new builds or kitchen remodels.”

9. Fabrics

Vintage fabrics and tapestries are often overlooked, but they offer endless possibilities in home decor. Latoyia Smith, owner of Lavish Furniture Flips, highlights the adaptability of vintage fabrics. “As a sustainable interior designer and furniture artist, there are items I am always keeping my eyes peeled for, and my number one is vintage fabrics and tapestry.” She suggests using these fabrics in a variety of ways—from layering them as table runners or tiebacks to using them as unique place settings. But one of her favorite uses is turning them into art. “You can simply frame fabric for a gallery wall or hang an antique rug for heirloom texture.”

10. Suitcases as decor

Libbie from the vintage blog, Rusticity Decor shares her love for vintage suitcases as a unique storage solution. “When I’m out thrifting, I always keep an eye out for vintage suitcases. They carry such a story and provide an aesthetically pleasing way to store collections or unsightly items.” Make sure to get creative with these vintage style home decor pieces. Libbie suggests, “Put them on a shelf, stash them under a table, or grab several and stack them on top of each other in a corner. It’s such a stylish way to store clutter while adding character to your space.”

11. Vintage globes

For history enthusiasts, vintage globes might be a fascinating addition to your home. Troy McElfresh of Mr. Bid Auctions recommends adding these to your wishlist. “Vintage globes are a fantastic find for both decor and collectors. Look for pre-1950s globes with detailed cartography, unique color schemes, and solid brass or wooden bases.” These globes often feature borders and countries that have since changed, making them especially appealing for their historical significance.

12. Limestone fountain

Moving on to the garden, vintage pieces are a perfect choice. One standout find is a vintage limestone fountain, which adds sophistication and a sense of history to any garden or courtyard.

“If you’re searching for a show-stopping element to elevate your home or garden, a vintage limestone fountain is a must-have,” says the team from the lifestyle blog, Monthly Favorites. “These timeless pieces bring an air of old-world charm and sophistication, aging gracefully with a natural patina that only enhances their character.” Beyond their visual appeal, limestone fountains are incredibly durable, ensuring they stay both beautiful and functional for generations.

When shopping for one, look for hand-chiseled details and natural weathering—indications of true craftsmanship. “Whether placed in a courtyard, entryway, or garden, a vintage limestone fountain isn’t just decor—it’s a legacy,” they add.

13. Reclaimed or recycled pieces

Incorporating reclaimed or recycled pieces into your decor is an eco-friendly way to add vintage style home decor into your home. “Reclaimed and recycled pieces are always a hit,” says Harlan Rose from the antique shop, FEA Home in Yonkers, NY. “Designers love using old pieces in new modern settings. For example, converting an antique door or window grate into a coffee table is a great way to decorate.”

Where can you find vintage decor?

There are countless places to find unique vintage style home decor. Vintage boutiques offer carefully curated selections, while estate sales and flea markets are perfect for uncovering hidden treasures. Thrift stores provide budget-friendly options full of surprises, and online marketplaces like eBay, Etsy, and Facebook Marketplace make shopping for vintage pieces more convenient than ever.

Creating the perfect space using vintage style home decor

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just beginning your vintage journey, each piece you bring into your home is a chapter of its own story. From timeless furniture to rare decorative accents, vintage style home decor offers an irresistible alternative to mass-produced pieces, infusing your space with character and craftsmanship. Next time you’re thrifting or antiquing, keep these curated treasures in mind—they could be the missing piece to your dream home. So, grab your shopping list, and start styling your home with vintage decor.

The post Your Definitive Vintage Style Home Decor Shopping List: 13 Must-Have Finds appeared first on Redfin | Real Estate Tips for Home Buying, Selling & More.