![The F-35’s future: The world’s most advanced stealth fighter and what comes next [Video]](https://breakingdefense.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2025/03/8477353.jpg?#)
The Government's "Domicile" Argument on Birth Citizenship
One thing that was clear from today's argument is that the Court will not reach the merits yet. After another argument in October, maybe. Or maybe not until the circuit courts have weighed in.The Solicitor General mentioned today the Government's merits argument rests in large part on the claim that "subject to the jurisdiction" in the Citizenship Clause requires that the parents of the children have a domicile within the United States. That's wrong for several reasons, but here's one that relates back to an argument that I made in some earlier posts.The children of "gypsies" were expressly mentioned as people who would get birth citizenship under the Citizenship Clause. Traditional "gypsies" did not have a domicile. Indeed, you might say that the lack of a domicile (e.g., "wandering band of gypsies") is what defined that group of people and explains why they were persecuted for centuries. You can't reconcile that with a domicile requirement for birth citizenship.
One thing that was clear from today's argument is that the Court will not reach the merits yet. After another argument in October, maybe. Or maybe not until the circuit courts have weighed in.
The Solicitor General mentioned today the Government's merits argument rests in large part on the claim that "subject to the jurisdiction" in the Citizenship Clause requires that the parents of the children have a domicile within the United States. That's wrong for several reasons, but here's one that relates back to an argument that I made in some earlier posts.
The children of "gypsies" were expressly mentioned as people who would get birth citizenship under the Citizenship Clause. Traditional "gypsies" did not have a domicile. Indeed, you might say that the lack of a domicile (e.g., "wandering band of gypsies") is what defined that group of people and explains why they were persecuted for centuries. You can't reconcile that with a domicile requirement for birth citizenship.
