The Dungeon of Palatable Pleasure: Sinister Bakers’ Mission to Create Devilishly Good Treats

When Christopher McCarthy learned how to cook and bake, it instilled in him a deeper purpose: taking care of others through the age-old culinary art. At the heart of Sinister Bakers, a truly one-of-a-kind joint in Erie, Colorado, he does just that, with an unexpectedly dark twist. Here, the frills and pastels of popular pastries are forgotten, making way for fear and gloom—all in good faith.

Photo Credit: Sinister Bakers

One part bakery, located in E(e)rie, one part cafe, located in Longmont, Sinister Bakers’ selection is as vibrant as it is scary. From devilishly delicious cakes and grimy muffins to savory coffin pies and sandwiches fleshed out with abundant toppings, it offers something unique for every seeker of flavor and adventure. Located amidst the walls of a local college campus, the cafe ensures that you’re never truly alone, haunted by the ghosts of people who stepped into this palatable dungeon and never left.

But no one in Erie is safe from Sinister Bakers’ domination. Ever since these mad scientists discovered the power of going digital, local villagers can order sweet darkness straight to their doors – whether they want to indulge in this blend of taste and torment themselves, or to harrow their enemies. While the bakery’s offering is certain to play on anyone’s unique fears, fellow sinisters can also revel in the magic of customization.

Photo Credit: Sinister Bakers

“There are no requests that are too outlandish,” says McCarthy, Sinister Bakers’ Master Patisserie. “In fact, whatever horrific image you can think of, we’ve probably made it before.”

The bakery is also frequently invited to cater large-scale events, from birthdays and anniversaries to graduations and workplace affairs. After all, serving Sinister Bakers’ witchcrafted cupcakes and other sorceries is the easiest way to spellbind your colleagues, friends, and family. “Every single item carries a bit of magic,” he adds. “But what you do with it? That’s completely within your control.”

Truly, it’s virtually impossible to resist this sinister charm. Among myriad potions and amalgamations, McCarthy highlights the bakery’s Boulder Bomb as its arguably most powerful weapon. Just imagine a devilishly delicious donut dough baked in a muffin tin, dipped in melted butter sourced from the medieval dungeons of Europe, and sprinkled with ashes from cinnamon and sugar. Don’t rainbow cupcakes and pink macarons sound a bit dull now?

Photo Credit: Sinister Bakers

The concept of Sinister Bakers has been brewing in McCarthy’s cauldron for decades. Its first flames sparked when, during times more grey and dismal than today, he started baking. His fluffy yet crunchy ciabatta quickly became a staple in his own family, savored in its true glory with nothing but a bit of butter. Cooking transformed into an integral part of the McCarthies’ lives, and every time they gathered in the kitchen, they would brainstorm the most grotesque descriptions and freaky names.

This laid the foundation for what Sinister Bakers is today. Guests can, for instance, enjoy a Devil’s Dawn Breakfast Sandwich or Mummy’s Wrap, followed by a rich and aromatic cup of Witches’ Brew. While the team doesn’t take itself seriously, it places grave importance on fresh and high-quality ingredients. Everything is sourced and harvested locally, and every coffee syrup, loaf of bread, or sandwich spread is homemade, with love.

This dark and dingy laboratory takes its commitment to the community one step further, often fulfilling last-minute requests for birthday cakes and parties alike. It just goes to show that, in Erie, Sinister Bakers’ grip can reach you wherever, whenever. “Our only mission is to make you feel and taste the difference,” concludes McCarthy. “And when a customer walks through our doors and leaves with a smile? That’s when we have mastered the culinary witchcraft.”

The post The Dungeon of Palatable Pleasure: Sinister Bakers’ Mission to Create Devilishly Good Treats appeared first on Haute Living.